ENGINEthe workshop behind Preservation, Inc.Preservation · Deepwell · Modernism · Historic · Jeffery Holley

LARC 2550C · 8 SEPTEMBER 2026 · JEFFERY’S LIVING CLASS NOTES

How did a movement become a system?

American preservation began with scattered acts of rescue. Over time, private campaigns, public parks, documentation programs, local law, protest, and federal policy formed a national practice.

CourseIntroduction to Historic Preservation
Class meeting8 September 2026
AssignmentOrganization summary due 14 September

Chapter 3: “History of the Preservation Movement”

BOOK

Norman Tyler, Ilene R. Tyler, and Ted J. Ligibel, Historic Preservation: An Introduction to Its History, Principles, and Practice, 3rd ed. (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2018), chap. 3.

The supplied archive contains nine screenshots of the chapter. Because the images do not show the printed page numbers, this guide uses archive-image locators rather than inventing page citations.

CLASS RECORD

Dan and Alexis, “Grassroots Preservation,” LARC 2550C class lecture and discussion, September 8, 2026.

Lecture locators give the approximate time in the class transcript. The transcript’s machine spellings have been corrected where the person or organization can be identified.

COURSE CALENDAR

Week 3: Preservation Movement(s) in the United States; Grassroots Preservation.

Class meets September 8. The preservation-organization summary is due September 14.

Two paths, then a merger

01

Private action

Citizens first rallied around famous people, patriotic memory, and threatened landmarks. Women’s groups and local associations supplied money, labor, and political force.

02

Public protection

Government first moved most clearly through natural scenery, western lands, archaeology, national monuments, and parks.

03

Documentation

HABS and later HAER, CRGIS, and HALS made recording a public duty. Measured drawings, photographs, maps, and histories preserve evidence even when a place is lost.

04

Local regulation

Charleston’s 1931 ordinance turned preservation from persuasion into public review, zoning, and certificates of appropriateness.

05

Loss as a catalyst

Urban renewal and the demolition of Penn Station showed that federal power and private development could erase both buildings and communities.

06

A national system

The National Trust joined private and public work in 1949. The National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 created the National Register, SHPOs, and the Advisory Council.

People, places, laws, works, and ideas

Read the ledger as a transfer of authority: from private rescue, to public ownership, to professional systems, and then toward wider cultural and environmental claims.

1791–1940 · Rescue becomes public practice
  1. Organizations
    Massachusetts Historical Society · American Antiquarian Society

    The Massachusetts society made the new nation’s records part of a distinct American identity. The Worcester-based antiquarian society then extended that collecting mission to a national nonprofit. Neither yet centered buildings, but both supplied preservation’s historical premise: the nation possessed a past worth keeping.

    Lecture 02:52
  2. Place
    Independence Hall · Philadelphia

    A successful campaign prevents demolition. Lafayette’s 1824 visit renews attention and helps turn the Old State House into a national shrine.

    Archive 1/9
  3. Place + person
    Touro Synagogue · Abraham Touro’s estate

    Funds from Abraham Touro’s estate repaired Newport’s colonial synagogue, built from 1759 to 1763. The case links family and religious identity to one of the country’s earliest building restorations and complicates the era’s usual emphasis on elite white Protestant men.

    Lecture 09:35
  4. People + place
    Uriah P. Levy and the Levy family · Monticello

    U.S. Navy officer Uriah Levy bought and repaired Jefferson’s house in 1836. His family protected it amid anti-Jewish hostility until the Thomas Jefferson Memorial Foundation acquired it in 1923. Preservation here depended on private stewardship across generations, not a single rescue.

    Lecture 09:35
  5. People + group
    Ann Pamela Cunningham · Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association

    After Congress declines to act, women organize a national private campaign to acquire and restore George and Martha Washington’s home.

    Archive 2/9
  6. Law + place
    Yellowstone National Park

    Federal preservation first centers on large natural landscapes rather than historic buildings.

    Archive 2/9
  7. Places
    Casa Grande · Mesa Verde

    Federal action responds to looting and loss at Indigenous sites. The chapter’s account also exposes the limits of treating Native heritage chiefly as federal property.

    Archive 2/9
  8. People + group
    Mary Jeffery Galt and Cynthia Beverley Tucker Coleman · Preservation Virginia

    The two women founded the Association for the Preservation of Virginia Antiquities to rescue Williamsburg’s deteriorating Powder Magazine. Now Preservation Virginia, it supplied the model for a statewide preservation nonprofit whose work grew from one threatened building to many sites.

    Lecture 22:42
  9. Group + Idaho
    Daughters of the American Revolution · O’Farrell Cabin

    The lineage society formed in 1890. Its Boise chapter took custody of John and Mary O’Farrell’s 1863 cabin and moved it across Fort Street in 1911, an early Idaho example of relocation used to prevent loss.

    Lecture 21:10
  10. Organization
    National Society of the Colonial Dames of America

    The women-led lineage society joined preservation, patriotic service, education, manuscripts, and museum work. Its federated state societies show how social networks could turn inherited identity and private means into national stewardship.

    Lecture 17:51
  11. Landscape
    Adirondack Park

    New York creates an early large public-private conservation landscape under the promise that state forest lands remain “forever wild.”

    Archive 2/9
  12. Law
    Antiquities Act · Theodore Roosevelt

    The president gains authority to proclaim national monuments on federal land; administration rests with the Department of the Interior.

    Archive 3/9
  13. Person + group
    Caroline Emmerton · House of the Seven Gables Settlement Association

    Emmerton joined social reform to preservation in Salem. The settlement work began in 1908; in 1910 she restored and opened the Turner-Ingersoll Mansion as a museum whose income supported services for immigrant families. Her restoration also reconstructed missing gables to fit the house’s literary identity.

    Lecture 22:42
  14. Agency
    National Park Service

    The new Interior agency manages national parks and later becomes the main federal administrator of preservation programs.

    Archive 3/9
  15. People + groups
    Mary B. Talbert · NACW · Frederick Douglass home

    At the urging of the Frederick Douglass Memorial and Historical Association, the National Association of Colored Women agreed in 1916 to retire Cedar Hill’s mortgage. President Mary B. Talbert led the campaign, which met its goal by the 1918 centennial of Douglass’s birth. The case shows a civil-rights organization becoming a preservation force when a place tied to Black history faced financial loss.

    Lecture 29:57
  16. Place + people
    Colonial Williamsburg · John D. Rockefeller Jr. · W. A. R. Goodwin

    A whole town becomes a major restoration project guided by a formal set of principles.

    Archive 3/9
  17. Place + person
    Greenfield Village · Henry Ford

    Ford relocates buildings into an “animated textbook,” gaining educational power while sacrificing original context.

    Archives 3–4/9
  18. Local law
    Charleston historic district

    The first regulatory historic district establishes architectural review and certificates of appropriateness.

    Archive 4/9
  19. Program
    Historic American Buildings Survey

    NPS, the Library of Congress, and AIA turn relief work into a national record of American building arts.

    Archive 4/9
  20. Law
    Historic Sites Act

    Federal policy calls for preserving nationally significant sites, buildings, and objects for public use.

    Archive 5/9
  21. Field + people
    Society of Architectural Historians · Turpin Bannister · Henry-Russell Hitchcock

    Architectural history became a national scholarly field through the Society of American Architectural Historians, organized at Harvard and led first by Turpin Bannister. Hitchcock’s studies of nineteenth- and twentieth-century design supplied a related form of activism: scholarship could make the unfashionable recent past visible before it disappeared.

    Lecture 38:39
1949–1979 · Protest, policy, and professionalization
  1. Organization
    National Trust for Historic Preservation

    Congress charters a national body to connect federal activity with local and private preservation.

    Archive 5/9
  2. Policy
    Housing Acts · urban renewal

    Federal clearance programs displace communities, especially African American neighborhoods, and make demolition a central preservation issue.

    Archive 5/9
  3. Program
    Mission 66

    NPS modernizes park infrastructure and visitor services. Richard Neutra’s later-demolished Gettysburg Cyclorama shows that one era’s improvement can become another era’s contested heritage.

    Archives 5–6/9
  4. People + works
    Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities · Rachel Carson, Silent Spring

    Jacobs defends living urban fabric; Carson links evidence, public writing, and environmental action. The movements develop in parallel.

    Archives 6–7/9
  5. Loss + law
    Penn Station demolition · New York City Landmarks Law

    A famous loss becomes political proof that admiration alone cannot protect a landmark.

    Archive 7/9
  6. Loss + Idaho
    Dewey Palace Hotel · Nampa

    Nampa lost its 1902 downtown landmark the same year New York lost Penn Station. Part of the site remained a parking lot decades later. Dan’s point was practical: mourning a past loss matters only if it sharpens action for places threatened now.

    Lecture 1:04:33
  7. Theory
    Venice Charter

    Conservation professionals set an international framework for monuments and sites, though the charter gives limited attention to landscape, social life, and finance.

    Archive 7/9
  8. Work + law
    With Heritage So Rich · National Historic Preservation Act

    The report helps produce a federal-state-local system: National Register, SHPOs, Advisory Council, surveys, and financial support.

    Archives 7–8/9
  9. Field + law
    Association for Preservation Technology · National Environmental Policy Act

    Professional technology and environmental review widen the tools and alliances of preservation.

    Archive 8/9
  10. People + Idaho
    Joan Carley, Mary Lesser, and others · Preservation Idaho

    Concern over rapid loss brought Idahoans together as the Idaho Historic Preservation Council, later called Preservation Idaho. It became the state’s only advocacy-centered preservation nonprofit, using education, collaboration, and public pressure across Idaho.

    Lecture 1:04:33
  11. Culture + finance
    U.S. Bicentennial · Tax Reform Act

    Popular history expands local participation while rehabilitation tax incentives make private investment part of preservation policy.

    Archive 8/9
  12. Theory
    Burra Charter

    Australia’s charter broadens conservation toward cultural significance, practice, and heritage beyond monuments alone.

    Archive 9/9
1980–2015 · Economics, rights, technology, and climate
  1. Program
    National Main Street Center

    The Main Street Approach links preservation with downtown organization, design, promotion, and economic vitality.

    Archive 9/9
  2. People + group
    Hubert-Jan Henket, Wessel de Jonge, and Theo Prudon · Docomomo

    Henket and de Jonge initiated Docomomo International in Eindhoven in 1988. Prudon led the launch of Docomomo US in New York in 1995. The network moved preservation’s date line forward by documenting and conserving buildings, sites, landscapes, and neighborhoods of the Modern Movement.

    Lecture 1:13:25
  3. Documentation
    CRGIS · Historic American Landscapes Survey

    Digital mapping, remote sensing, and landscape records enlarge federal documentation beyond individual buildings.

    Archive 5/9
  4. Law
    Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act

    NAGPRA recognizes Native rights in ancestors and cultural objects and requires return in defined circumstances.

    Archive 9/9
  5. Organization
    Trail of Tears Association

    The NPS and Trail of Tears Advisory Council helped form the association; the Cherokee Nation and Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians signed its incorporation papers. Native and non-Native members work through state chapters to protect routes, landscapes, records, and “witness buildings” tied to the 1838–39 forced removal.

    Lecture 1:10:03
  6. Center
    National Center for Preservation Technology and Training

    The Natchitoches center joins science, research, training, and preservation practice.

    Archive 9/9
  7. Programs
    Save America’s Treasures · Preserve America

    Federal grants, matching funds, recognition, and heritage tourism connect stewardship with local economic strategy.

    Archive 9/9
  8. Advocacy
    National Treasures program · Rosenwald Schools

    The National Trust turns endangered-place publicity into direct coalition building, grants, and legal advocacy.

    Archive 9/9
  9. Climate
    Paris Agreement

    Climate policy raises questions of cultural loss, adaptation, damage, responsibility, and the future of at-risk heritage.

    Archive 9/9
  10. People + network
    Megan Springate and Mark Meinke · Rainbow Heritage Network

    The co-founders created a national network for recognizing and preserving LGBTQ places, histories, and heritage. The lecture used Stonewall to show how widening the field changes not only which sites count, but whose knowledge and civil-rights history guide their interpretation.

    Lecture 1:13:25

A working vocabulary

Antiquarianism

Study and collection of old things before historic preservation became a named field.

Archive 1/9
Grassroots preservation

Local action led by residents, owners, volunteers, and civic groups rather than imposed from the top.

Archives 1–4/9
Reactive preservation

Organizing that begins only after a place faces demolition or redevelopment. Penn Station and the Dewey Palace show how a major loss can build political will, but too late for the resource itself.

Lecture 1:01:28
Proactive preservation

Surveying, organizing, educating, and adopting tools before a threat hardens into a demolition plan.

Lecture 1:01:28
Witness building

A building that survives along a historic route or landscape and provides physical evidence of events it observed, even when its owners were not the central historical actors.

Lecture 1:10:03
Building zoo

An informal and often critical term for unrelated historic buildings moved to one collection. It names the loss of original setting while leaving open the question of whether relocation is better than demolition.

Lecture 43:48
Landmark tradition

The early focus on famous people, patriotic events, and exceptional individual buildings.

Archives 1–2/9
Context

The setting, relationships, and cultural landscape that give a resource meaning. Greenfield Village tests what relocation removes.

Archives 3–4/9
Certificate of appropriateness

A local board’s approval for exterior work governed by a historic-district ordinance.

Archive 4/9
Urban renewal

Publicly funded clearance and redevelopment that often displaced residents and destroyed historic neighborhoods.

Archive 5/9
Documentation

Measured drawings, photographs, histories, maps, and digital records that preserve evidence.

Archives 4–5/9
Professionalization

The growth of laws, agencies, standards, training, research, and paid expertise around preservation.

Archives 4–9/9
Heritage tourism

Using cultural resources to support visitation and local income; economic gain must still be tested against who benefits and who bears the cost.

Archive 9/9
Repatriation

The return of ancestors and cultural objects to Native nations and lineal descendants.

Archive 9/9
Jane Jacobs

Writer and activist who argued that older buildings and mixed urban fabric sustain community life.

Archive 6/9
Rachel Carson

Writer and scientist whose evidence on pesticides helped animate the modern environmental movement.

Archive 7/9
Ann Pamela Cunningham

Organizer who turned Mount Vernon’s threatened condition into a national women-led preservation campaign.

Archive 2/9
John D. Rockefeller Jr.

Patron whose support made Colonial Williamsburg a defining whole-town restoration.

Archive 3/9
Henry Ford

Collector who treated relocated buildings as an educational village, raising lasting questions about authenticity and setting.

Archives 3–4/9
Michael Tomlan

Scholar quoted on preservation’s 1970s–80s turn toward business, incentives, and development.

Archive 8/9

Ways to test the chapter

Power

A movement is heat; a system is plumbing

Public anger creates pressure. Law, money, offices, records, and review procedures decide where that pressure can travel.

Evidence

Documentation is an architectural witness

A drawing or photograph cannot stop demolition, but it can keep loss from becoming silence.

Economics

Preservation changes the balance sheet

Tax credits and heritage tourism convert old fabric from a perceived obstacle into an asset. The harder question is who receives the return.

Authority

Every rescue redraws the table

Mount Vernon empowered private women; Charleston empowered a review board; NHPA empowered agencies. NAGPRA shifted authority toward Native peoples.

Federal review

Section 106 revisions

Proposed 2026 changes test whether the system built after 1966 still gives the public and affected communities a meaningful voice. Follow the National Trust’s record →

Climate + sovereignty

Pamunkey Indian Reservation

Sea-level rise threatens archaeology, buildings, traditional plants, clay, and fishing grounds together. The case makes clear why cultural landscape cannot be reduced to architecture. Read the case →

Downtown economics

The “connection economy”

Main Street America’s 2026 work treats shops and third places as social infrastructure, not merely retail space. It updates the chapter’s argument that preservation can support living local economies. See current Main Street work →

Loss + repair

Independence Square drainage

Repairs beneath a famous civic landscape show the quieter side of preservation: maintenance, water management, and the work needed to keep a landmark in public use. Read the NPS account →

These metaphors and current applications are interpretive additions by Jeffery Holley, not claims made by the textbook or official University of Idaho course material.

Grassroots preservation changes who may act

DEFINITION

Community upward

Grassroots preservation begins with people who value a culturally or socially important place and organize in response to demolition, redevelopment, displacement, neglect, or erasure. They need not begin as trained preservationists. The work itself can make them preservationists.

PATTERN

Women built the early network

Women led many of the first durable organizations: Cunningham at Mount Vernon; Galt and Coleman in Virginia; Emmerton in Salem; Talbert and the NACW at Cedar Hill; and Carley, Lesser, and others in Idaho. Their civic clubs, lineage groups, money, and labor supplied power before preservation had a profession.

POWER

Access shaped the movement

Class discussion identified wealth, patriotism, minority communities, and service to others as recurring forces. Private means made early rescues possible, but also narrowed which histories seemed worthy. Touro Synagogue, the Levy family, Cedar Hill, the Trail of Tears, and LGBTQ heritage make that boundary visible and push it outward.

METHOD

Saving changes the evidence

Relocation can prevent demolition while severing setting and association. Reconstruction can make a public story legible while removing later layers. Greenfield Village, Pioneer Village, the O’Farrell Cabin, and Colonial Williamsburg turn preservation treatment into an interpretive choice, not a neutral act.

PUBLIC STORY

Interpret the whole place

Student comments on Mount Vernon and Colonial Williamsburg stressed experience as well as fabric: rooms, grounds, living-history staff, and the treatment of slavery. A preserved building gains public meaning through the story told there—and through the parts that story once omitted.

PRACTICE

Loss must produce foresight

Penn Station and the Dewey Palace show the limits of reactive work. The useful lesson is not endless mourning but earlier survey, public education, advocacy, and law. Preservation becomes more effective when a community knows what it values before a crisis.

Summary of a preservation organization

StatusIn progress
SubmissionOne attempt allowed
Required formatTwo pages · double-spaced · Chicago citations

Select a historic or currently active preservation organization and explain its history, mission, preservation efforts, community, and significance to the broader movement. The organization may be local, state, regional, or national and may represent grassroots advocacy, a historical society, a preservation commission, a nonprofit, or a particular community or historic theme.

01 · ORGANIZATION

Name, time, and place

What is the organization called, and when and where was it established?

02 · MISSION

Reason for forming

What primary goals, threats, or opportunities caused the organization to form?

03 · PRESERVATION FOCUS

What it values

What places, resources, architectural types, communities, or historic themes does it protect?

04 · IMPACT

What changed

Identify significant preservation accomplishments or contributions—and explain why they matter.

05 · COMMUNITY

Who acted

Who founded or supported the organization, and which community or communities did it represent?

06 · REFLECTION

Place in the movement

Explain what makes the organization significant to the broader historic preservation movement.

The Miami Design Preservation League: Proactive Preservation in a Resort Town

Jeffery Holley’s draft answers all six objectives and connects MDPL to Tyler, Tyler, and Ligibel and the September 8 lecture. The preserved file contains four pages of text plus a bibliography.

Submission check: The assignment permits two double-spaced pages. Compress the text before using the single submission attempt.

OPEN THE PAPER AND ORIGINAL PDF →

← RETURN TO ENGINE

WHAT STAYS? · LARC 2550C

Five cases. Trace the movement.

QUESTION 1 OF 50 DAY STREAK